Honestly, trying to track Aubrey Plaza dating history is like trying to solve one of those puzzles where the pieces are all different shades of black. She’s famously private. Or weird. Usually both. Most people still think of her as the deadpan April Ludgate, but her actual romantic life has been far more grounded—and recently, far more tragic—than her chaotic public persona suggests.
The biggest misconception right now? That she's "dating" around Hollywood. In reality, Plaza is navigating a period of profound personal loss. For over a decade, her heart belonged to one man, filmmaker Jeff Baena. Their relationship wasn't just a romance; it was a creative engine that fueled some of the best indie cinema of the last ten years.
The Quiet Marriage to Jeff Baena
Aubrey Plaza and Jeff Baena were the ultimate "if you know, you know" couple. They started dating way back in 2011. They didn't do the flashy red carpet reveals or the sappy anniversary posts. Instead, they made movies.
If you've seen Life After Beth or The Little Hours, you’ve seen their relationship in action. Jeff directed, Aubrey starred (and often produced). It worked. They were a team. Then, in May 2021, she casually dropped the "husband" bomb on Instagram. No big PR announcement. Just a caption referring to him as her "darling husband."
A Wedding Born of Boredom
She later told Ellen DeGeneres that they got married in their backyard during the COVID-19 lockdown. It was their 10-year anniversary. They were bored. They joked about getting married, and Jeff—ever the challenger—said they probably couldn't pull it off that fast.
Plaza, being Plaza, found a website called 1hourmarriage.com. A guy in a Hawaiian shirt showed up at their house in Los Feliz. They got hitched. It was "witch-core," according to Aubrey, complete with a rosemary crown and a love altar.
The Tragedy of 2025
The narrative around Aubrey Plaza dating changed forever on January 3, 2025. That was the day Jeff Baena passed away at the age of 47. The Los Angeles County Medical Examiner later confirmed it was a death by suicide.
It was a shock that rippled through the industry. But for Plaza, it was personal and complicated. Reports later surfaced that the couple had actually quietly separated in September 2024, just a few months before his death. They were going through what many long-term couples face—peaks and valleys.
"Sometimes I just want to dive into it and just be in it. Then sometimes I just look at it, and sometimes I try to get away from it. But, it's always there."
That’s how she described her grief to Amy Poehler on the Good Hang podcast in August 2025. She called it a "giant ocean of awfulness." She’s been incredibly raw about the fact that life doesn't just "go back to normal" after something like that.
That Time She Almost Married Michael Cera
Before the Jeff Baena era, there was the Michael Cera era. This is the fun bit of trivia that usually pops up when people search for her dating history. They met on the set of Scott Pilgrim vs. the World in 2010.
They dated for about a year and a half. At one point, they were driving through Las Vegas and almost got married just so they could get a divorce immediately. Why? So they could call each other "my ex-husband" and "my ex-wife" while they were still in their early 20s.
It's such a specific, weird brand of humor that explains exactly why they worked as a couple. They’re still friends. Cera has even gone on record recently praising her work as a producer, calling her commitment "amazing."
Where Things Stand in 2026
As of early 2026, Aubrey Plaza is not publicly dating anyone. She has been focused on her work and her healing. Just a few weeks ago, in late December 2025, she made headlines for delisting the $6.5 million Los Feliz home she had shared with Jeff.
She had initially put it on the market in September, but it seems she had a change of heart. Deciding to stay in the home where you built a life is a heavy choice. It signals that she’s still processing, still sitting with the memory of the man she spent thirteen years with.
Identifying the Reality
If you see tabloids claiming she’s "moving on" with a new co-star, take it with a grain of salt. Plaza has always been a "work-first" person.
- Her current status: Widowed/Single.
- Focus: Production through her company, Evil Hag Productions.
- Recent sightings: Red carpets for projects like Honey Don't!, but usually solo or with cast members.
The truth about Aubrey Plaza dating is that there isn't much "dating" to report. She’s navigating a very public career while dealing with a very private, very heavy type of grief. She isn't looking for the next big Hollywood romance; she’s looking for the next big story to tell.
If you’re following her journey, the best thing to do is watch the work. Her performances lately have a different kind of weight to them. Grief changes people. It’s clearly changed her, too.
Actionable Insight: When looking for updates on Aubrey Plaza, look toward her production credits. She often processes her personal life through the characters she creates and the directors she chooses to work with. Avoid the "shipping" rumors on social media—they rarely align with her actual, much more private reality.